Tom Ingram and Associates Home |
$1 Million+ Services Sale Database
and Success Story Details*
Note: This is an active research site that is continually being updated. Please be patient with any incompleteness as we work together to learn and understand... If you notice any mistakes or errors, please let us know immediately...
Index of "$1 million+ wins". (Find details by searching page for companies you are interested in below.)
Software and Process Outsourcing Related Services Successes |
Merchandising Services Outsourcing for Consumer Goods Successes | Industrial Products Services Successes |
AARP
AIG
AMD
American Airlines
Anheuser Busch
Atari
Bank of NY
BMW
California Department of Social Services
Celanese
Cessna Aircraft
Conagra
Deloitte & Touche
Energen (Natural Gas Provider)
Entergy
Exxon Mobil
FedEx Kinkos
Fireman's Fund
GAP
Gillette Glaxo
Goldman Sachs
GTE
Hasbro Toys
HR Textron (Manufacturer of Hydraulics):
Igloo
Intel Johnson & Johnson
Kodak
Lehman Brothers
Lennox Air Conditioning
Los Angeles Department of Water and Power
Los Angeles Unified School District
Macy's
Marley Air Conditioning
McDonnell Douglas Aircraft
McKesson
Meridian Oil
Merrill Lynch
Mervyns
Metropolitan Life
NASDAC
NCR
NY Life
NYSE
Owens Corning
Pennsylvania Department of Motor Vehicles
Pepsi Pfizer
Procter & Gamble Roche
SAB Brewing of South Africa
Safety Kleen Sandoz Schering Plough
Shell Oil SmithKline
State of Texas
Texas Commerce Bank
Texas Instruments
Truman Medical Center
Union Pacific Resources
United States Air Force
US Borax
Utah Department of Motor Vehicles
Valero
VF Corp. (Wrangler Jeans)
Western Union Wyeth Ayerst
Zales |
Manufacturers
Activision
Bose Corporation
Canon
Casio
ConAgra
Crave
Dole
First Look Studios
Fox & Sony
Fuji Photo
General
Mills
Genius Products
Heinz USA (Heinz PET, Orida, Weightwatchers,
Starkist)
Henkel
Kimberly Clark Kraft
Land O'Lakes
LG
Lionsgate
Mattel
Panasonic
Paramount
Phillips Electronics
Procter& Gamble
Quaker Oats Reckitt
Benckiser
Samsung
Sharp Electronics Corporation
Sony Electronics
Thomson (THOMSON CONSUMER ELECTRONICS) Unilever
Universal
Warner
Ahold
Dollar General
Harris Teeter
Kroger
Longs
Pamida
Pathmark
Rite Aide
Sams
SuperValu
Target
Walgreens
Walmart
|
ABB** Fenwick** GE Energy, Power Turbines** Heidelberg (Heidelberger Druckmaschinen Ag)** Hilti**
L'air Liquide**
Rockwell Automation** Schneider Electric** SKF**
First Command (Insurance to Military Families) |
Success Story Details...
Tom Ingram Successes: 1.0 How We Sold $10 Million in New Outsourced Services to Celanese in 90 Days* CLICK HERE 2.0 How We Sold $5.5 Million in New Outsourced Services to Procter & Gamble in 60 Days* CLICK HERE .**** 3.0 How We Sold $1.2 Million in New Outsourced Services at 50% Margin to General Mills, Dole, ConAgra, Reckitt and Benckiser in One Year CLICK HERE .**** 4.0 Sales Pipeline Discipline, How we helped client team: 590 Leads Forecast at $11,668,000 Were Qualified, Tracked and Closed Over 2 1/2 Years in 30 Separate Transactions totaling $6.5 Million Sold (some explanation required)* CLICK HERE to view pipeline system **** 5.0 MY FAVORITE EXAMPLE: How I sold one process improvement project that led to $7 million+ in services sold and 100+ web site development projects: CLICK HERE 5.5 How We Sold $3.2 Million in New Services to the State of Texas, Directly Contributing to a $21 Million Savings CLICK HERE |
Mary Twain: Former VP of Sales
for Documentum, led sales growth from
$2 million to $70 million in four years.
CLICK HERE for
Mary's Full Credentials* (660.1)
(660.2)
SmithKline: 55%+ Gross
Profit. Sold Pilot for $75,000. Team ultimately sold full
Implementation for $2 million+* Sale
of document management system for new drug submission to FDA ultimately
resulted in $8 million+ services sold.
(These are averages for
sales during the company's high growth period. Individual sales
varied). (MT)
(660.3)
(660.4)
(660.5)
(660.6)
Johnson & Johnson:
55%+ Gross Profit. Sold Pilot for $75,000. Team ultimately
sold full Implementation for $2 million+*
Sale of document management system for new drug
submission to FDA ultimately resulted in $8 million+ services sold.
(These are
averages for sales during the company's high growth period.
Individual sales varied). (MT)
(660.7)
|
Ed Slayton Successes (Click for Credentials)
Personally sold the following:
(712)
Procter & Gamble:
$3 Million+ Sale at 50%+ blended gross profit
for software, services and maintenance*.
Stopped selling to IT, sold to
CFO, increased average gross margins by 27%.
Application sold was imaging and workflow for Accounts Payable,
Accounts Receivable,
Deduction Management (the "short pay" problem),
archiving of documents and reports, with interface to non-SAP
financial system (ES, confirmation pending)
(713)
Conagra: $1
Million+ Sale at 50%+ blended gross profit for software, services
and maintenance*.
Stopped selling to IT, sold to CFO, increased average gross margins
by 27%.
Application sold was imaging and workflow for Accounts Payable,
Deduction Management (the "short pay"
problem), archiving
of documents and reports, New Product Development / Introduction,
with interface to non-SAP financial system (ES)
(715)
VF Corp. (Wrangler Jeans): $500,000+
Sale at 50%+ blended gross profit for software, services and
maintenance*.
Stopped selling to IT, sold to CFO, increased
average gross margins by 27%.
Application sold was imaging and workflow for
Deduction Management (the "short pay" problem)
archiving of documents and
reports, with interface to financial system. (ES)
(716) Celanese: $500,000+
Sale at 50%+ blended gross profit for software, services and
maintenance*.
Stopped selling to IT, sold to CFO, increased average gross margins
by 27%.
Application sold was imaging and workflow for
Deduction Management (the "short pay" problem),
archiving of documents and reports, with interface to financial
system. (ES)
(717)
Exxon Mobil:
$1 Million+ Sale at 50%+ blended gross profit
for software, services and maintenance*.
Stopped selling to IT, sold to CFO, increased average gross margins
by 27%.
Application sold was imaging and document management for pipeline
inspection reports, archiving of documents and reports, with
interface to SAP (ES)
(718)
Texas Instruments:
$1 Million+ Sale at 50%+ blended gross profit for software, services
and maintenance*.
Stopped selling to IT,
sold to CFO, increased average gross margins by 27%.
Application sold was imaging and workflow for Accounts Payable,
Accounts Receivable and archiving of documents and reports, with
interface to SAP. Retained client for many years and sold
replacement system from another company when client was ready to
upgrade. (ES)
(719)
Deloitte & Touche:
$1 Million+ Sale at
50%+ blended gross profit for software, services and maintenance*.
Stopped selling to IT, sold to CFO, increased average gross margins
by 27%.
Application sold was
imaging and workflow for Accounts Payable, General Ledger, Human
Resources and Project Accounting with interface to SAP at 125
locations. (ES)
(720)
Owens Corning:
$1 Million+ Sale at
50%+ blended gross profit for software, services and maintenance*.
Stopped selling to IT, sold to CFO, increased average gross margins
by 27%.
Application sold was imaging and workflow for Accounts Payable,
Accounts Receivable, Global Consolidation of Financial Reporting and
Tax, archiving of documents and reports, with interface to SAP (ES)
(722)
GTE: $1
Million+ Sale at 50%+ blended gross profit for software, services
and maintenance*.
Stopped selling to IT, sold to CFO, increased
average gross margins by 27%.
Application sold was imaging and workflow for Accounts Receivable,
General Ledger, archiving of regulatory documents and reports, with
interface to SAP (ES)
(724)
Valero: $1
Million+ Sale at 50%+ blended gross profit for software, services
and maintenance*.
Stopped selling to IT, sold to CFO, increased average gross margins
by 27%.
Application sold was imaging and document management for pipeline
inspection reports, archiving of documents and reports, with
interface to SAP (ES)
(725)
Anheuser Busch: $1
Million+ Sale at 50%+ blended gross profit for software, services
and maintenance*.
Stopped selling to IT, sold to CFO, increased average gross margins
by 27%.
Application sold was imaging and workflow for Accounts Payable,
archiving of documents and reports, with interface to SAP (ES)
|
Kurt Devin Summary Background and Results Record
(631) Kodak, Closed $10 Million+ in Outsourcing Services for Application Development, Infrastructure Support.* Associate lead sales team. (KD) |
Matt Masters Summary Background and Results Record
(652) Zales, Sold $10 Million+ in Outsourcing Services for Application Development, PeopleSoft and Retek Implementations.* Project in Trouble, Over Budget By 300%. Associate took over project, removed problem consulting firm and completed project on time. 1400 locations. Category: Project in Trouble (MM)
(655) Igloo, Sold and Delivered $6.5 Million IT Hardware "Swap-Out" Needed Due to Acquisition.* Included migrating all in-house developed applications to new IBM mainframe. Included accounting, manufacturing and sales order processing. (Dollar figure includes hardware and services). (MM) |
Bill Gerst Summary Background and Results Record (661) US Borax: $8 Million Sale of Full IT Outsourcing (Application Development plus Infrastructure)* (BG) (663) HR Textron (Manufacturer of Hydraulics): $13 Million Sale of Full IT Outsourcing (Application Development plus Infrastructure)* (BG)S(664) Western Union: $268 Million Sale of Full IT Outsourcing (Application Development plus Infrastructure)* (BG)Lead Sa(BG) |
Ted Kale Summary Background and Results Record (668)
Quaker Oats: $14 Million Sale of Services Resulted
in $78 Million in Savings*. Savings
Primarily in Manufacturing and Procurement Areas.
Services included
consulting, training, administration, communications and awards programs to
encourage all employees to find cost savings. (TK)
(669) Kraft: $4.5 Million Sale of Services for Incentive Program to Stimulate Cooperation, Cross Selling, Coordination, Cost Sharing, Etc. Between Kraft Brands. (TK) |
John Wagoner Summary
Background and Results
(672) (673)
American Airlines: $68 Million Sale of Network
Upgrade over 15 Months. $40
Million Services Component*. Involved
250 Sites. (JW) (674)
FedEx Kinkos: $215 Sale of
Application Upgrade over Three Months*.
(JW) (675)
FedEx Kinkos: $1 Million Sale of Installation of
Large, Banner Printers over Four Years*. (Includes
the cost of the hardware.) (JW) (676)
FedEx Kinkos: $8 Million+ Help Desk Contract Over
Four Years*.
Associate inherited the contract in trouble.
Returned the situation to health and long term customer. (JW) |
Scott Ransom Summary Background and Results Record
(677)
Fortune 10
Global Consumer Goods Manufacturer
: $350 Million per Year in Outsourced Services,
including Business Process Outsourcing and Full IT Outsourcing*.
Started as Finance and Accounting
Outsourcing and grew significantly. (SR) (678)
Top
Tier Global Beverage Manufacturer / Bottler:
Grew to $15 Million per Year in Outsourced IT Services.*
(SR) (679)
Global Consumer Goods Manufacturer (Bakery, Beverage,
Retail, Food Service): Grew by 15%+ to $62 Million per Year in Outsourced
Services. Included IT Outsourcing, Application Development and Business
Process Outsourcing*.
(SR) (680)
Leading Tobacco Company: $135 Million in Outsourced
Services over Five Years. Primarily IT Outsourcing, but Growing in SAP
Application Support.* (SR) (681)
Leading Brewery: $75 Million per Year in Outsourced
Services, including Application Development, IT Outsourcing, Finance, Accounting
and Business Process Outsourcing*.
Client saved $500 million+ through joint venture / merger
with SAB Brewing of South Africa. Market capitalization increased by $2
billion in 60 days because investors saw that the joint venture / merger was
going to produce the promised cost savings.
(SR) (706)
Leading Global Chemical Company: Closed $4.2
Billion, 10 Year Sale of IT Outsourcing Services*
Largest Outsourcing Sale Ever Sold to an External Client.
Won over 17 competitive RFPs by assembling industry talent team, had solutions
to industry problems. Won the large deal at
lower margins, but used as foothold to gain trust and close $1 Billion in higher
margin SAP application development work.
Contract is still in place after 13 years. (SR) (682)
Leading CPG Data Analysis Company: $100 Million
Renewal of Outsourced Services.* Services included Mainframe Operations,
Application Development, Business Process Outsourcing.
Lost part of the business to a large off-shore
competitor, but won the business back due to superior performance.
(SR) (683) Additional significant sales to Global Leader in Home Care, Personal Care and Adhesive Technologies along with the other top tier Beverage Manufacturer*. (SR)
(683.1) Hillenbrand / Forethought Success Creating Standalone
Services Business: Subsidiary Batesville Casket,
well known as an efficient manufacturer, failed
four times to start a pre-paid funeral services business.
A "skunk-works" effort resulted in the stand alone business, Forethought, which
sold $900 million in services (policy) revenue in
its first 30 months. (SR) |
Doug Preston Summary Background and Results Record
(684)
Wal*Mart: $30 Million of Outsourced Services
Delivered in Three Months*.
Associate was a senior member of the sales team and built
the labor staffing and execution plan that convinced Wal*Mart that the project
could be done. Associate then oversaw the
completion of the work.
Work was performed in stores all over the United States.
Associate was approximately
15% responsible for the sales win. (DP) (685)
Land O'Lakes: $0 to $15 Million in Outsourced
Services in 12 Months.* 10% of client's
sales to retailers were consuming 40% to 70% of labor cost and energy.
Associate designed the team and outsourced business process services to
streamline these orders. Associate
was 15% to 20% responsible for the sales win. (DP) (686)
Kimberly Clark: $0 to $35 Million in Outsourced
Services in 12 Months.* Reduced Custom
Orders by 70% in 8 Months.
Associate was approximately 10% responsible for the sales win. (DP) (687)
Heinz USA (Heinz PET, Orida, Weightwatchers, Starkist):
$0 to $5 Million in Outsourced Services in 12
Months.* HInes needed to combine
orders from five separate operating companies into a single order source to meet
retailer demands for "fewer vendors." Associate
designed and delivered the solution. Associate was approximately 30%
responsible for the sales win. (DP) |
Stuart Todd Specialist
in Consumer Electronics, Currently Unavailable |
Ron Davis, Specialist in Sales of Services to Consumer Electronics Firms. Companies sold to: (712) Fuji Photo: Gross Profit at 50%+, Net Profit at 25%+ on $5 Million of Outsourced Services*. Accomplished through "dedicated team" approach. (RD) (713) Casio: Gross Profit at 40%+ on $3 Million of Outsourced Services*. Accomplished through "assisted selling and training" approach. (RD) (714) Panasonic: Gross Profit at 40%+ on $1 Million+ of Outsourced Services*. Included installation and training services. (RD) (715) Phillips Electronics: Gross Profit at 40%+ on $1 Million+ of Outsourced Services*. Included installation, training and merchandising services. (RD) (715) Samsung: Gross Profit at 40%+ on $1 Million+ of Outsourced Services*. Significant work involving Walmart, details upon request. (RD) Additional $1 Million+ Services Sold to Consumer Electronics Companies by RD:
|
Dick Zell - Summary Background
(173)
Procter and Gamble
Practice: Closed $5.5 Million in Outsourcing
Services in 60 Days with P&G*
Led teams providing
outsourced services to P&G
for 10 years+, averaging over $5 million per year at 40%+ gross margins.
Maintained revenue stream and P&G trust despite failure of two parent companies.
Changes created unusual circumstances and opportunity, including reduced gross
margin.
Contact
Tom Ingram and Associates for details.
(DZ)
(174) Grew Services Revenues from $0 to $15 Million per Year with Fortune 50 Manufacturer.* Sustained Hourly Rate of 25% Above Industry for 10 Years. Generated $50 Million+ Incremental Sales for Manufacturer. Phase 1 cost savings of $1.7 million. Reduced Average Hourly Cost (including overhead) from $38 per hour to $26 per hour for 76 people. RIGHT FIELD MERCHANDISER IN RIGHT PLACE, WHEN NEEDED: Increased Store Visits by 25% for Same Budget Dollars. Comprehensive Training Makes The Difference. Ultimately Reduced Full Time Staff by 50%.Category: General Merchandise (DZ)
(175) Grew Services Revenues from $0 to $12 Million per Year with Distributor.* Saved $7 Million Per Year by Outsourcing In-house Merchandising Team. Resulted in $38.5 Million Sales Increase Per Year for Distributor (from 5.5% Market Share Gain - Taken from #1 Competitor!) New Product Cut-In Rate Raised from 70% to 99%+. 65% Full Time / 35% Part Time Work Force Changed to 30% Full Time / 70% Part Time. Complex and confidential case study. Contact Tom Ingram and Associates for details.Category: Entertainment (DZ) (176) “How We Found $7 Million In Annual Outsourcing Cost Savings”– Where to Look - Internal Cost Estimates Often Do Not Include Everything.* Complex and confidential case study. Contact Tom Ingram and Associates for details.Category: Entertainment (DZ)
(177) Custom Services Program with Inventory Replenishment Results in Distributor Sales Growing from $0 to $27 Million in Less Than One Year. Custom System Made It Difficult for Distributor to Beat Down The Hourly Rate or Switch to a Merchandising Competitor.* Helped client earn distribution in five more categories. Warehouse sold out within 30 days, accessories selling at a 50% increase over the previous year. Built trust with difficult retailer. Merchandiser’s reps trusted to place orders in the stores, resulting in nearly 100% of stores placing a weekly order. Merchandising problems decreased at same time as sales expanded rapidly. (DZ) |
Mark Ayers
- Summary Background (728)
High Margin
Win, SAP, Oracle, BAAN,
Peoplesoft Application Services Unit*:
Maintained 25% Pre-Tax Profit, 50%+ Gross Profit While Growing Unit From $42
Million to $180 Million in 18 Months.
Growth was extremely rapid due to year 2000 implementations.
(MA) (729)
High Margin
Win, IT Infrastructure
Outsourcing Services Unit*:
Maintained 20% Pre-Tax Profit While Growing Unit From $1.2 Billion to $2.9
Billion in 24 Months.
Switched from product resale strategy to outsourced services strategy.
(MA) |
Bill Seven
- Summary Background (714)
McKesson: $500,000+ Sale
at 50%+ blended gross profit for software, services and maintenance*.
Stopped selling to IT, sold to CFO,
increased average gross margins by 27%. Application
sold was imaging and workflow for Trade
Funds / Promotions Reconciliation,
Deduction Management (the "short pay" problem),
archiving of documents and reports, with interface to financial system
(BS) |
Roger
Spar, former Amdocs executive,
(Specialist in Costing and High Margin IT Services Sales)
(602) Services
Company Three Times as Profitable as Industry, Sustained Over Time.*
“A Little Bit of
Software Sells a LOT of Services”.
Services Outsell
Software
By
20 to 1.
Gross Profit Strong, 39%
Average Over Ten Years. Strong
Focus on Single Industry Niche – Telecom.
22% Average Sales
Growth Over 10 Years, Primarily Organic, Some Acquisitions.
Effective “Major Customer Focus”, 75% of Revenues Come from Three
Customers.
Great Customer Service is Not
Enough. Became Differentiated, High
Value, Indispensible Partner to Key Customers.
Price to Earnings Ratio
– Average 125 Over 10 Years.
After startup / high growth period,
P/E averaging about 20. Summary Background:
(Amdocs provides primarily billing systems and services to the wireless /
telecom industry)
|
=================Drug Retailer Successes (often cannot
disclose full names and details)================ (4)* $25 Million Sale of Services, 90 Day Cost Savings: Manufacturer Outsources Merchandising Work, Improves Execution from 90% to 98%, Saves $750,000 to $1,250,000 (estimated*): Associate led team that took over $25 million in merchandising work for the manufacturer. Associate conducted analysis that showed that manufacturer was overlooking significant costs. Salary and benefits for 1,200 reps were reduced by 20%+ (estimated.) Entire program was deployed in 90 days. Manufacturer was confident enough in the Associate's team that it provided up-front cash to fund the initiative. Goal was to provide the same or greater levels of service at a reduced cost. Program continued successfully for many years.Success Story Details Category: Pharmaceutical, Drug, OTC, Convenience (CS) (8)* $1 Million Per Week, Eight Times! New Item Speed to Shelf: New Item on Shelves in 20,000 Stores in Two Weeks! Effort was So Successful, it was Repeated 5 More Times.* As president, associate led multiple new item launches where a prescription drug was being converted to "over the counter." These launches required 20,000+ stores to be merchandised in two weeks, a 5-6 month planning and coordination cycle and working side by side with manufacturer. Associate's firm did several additional launches for the same manufacturer and others, totaling 6 major launches. Extremely difficult work to execute in so short a time frame.Success Story Details Category: Pharmaceutical, Drug, OTC (LC) (11)* $1 Million+ Services Sold, New Item Speed to Shelf, Taking Over Where Other Merchandising Organization Failed, Warehouse Sold Out in One Week!*: Associate led effort for a major pharmaceutical manufacturer to complete a new item introduction after failure by previous merchandising organization. After one week of execution on the launch, manufacturer called to say that inventories were depleted in their warehouses due to the surge in sales. Manufacturer credited the sales surge solely to the speed to shelf execution.Category: Drug (TE) (22)* $1 Million+ Services Sold, 20% Improvement in New Item Speed to Shelf. Shared Merchandising Teams (Broker Coverage) Not Getting Job Done. Established Dedicated Team Program for Fortune 500 Health and Beauty Manufacturer in Mass Merchandising (Wal*Mart) and Drug Channels*. Syndicated model being used was falling short in out of stocks, void fills and display compliance. Also provided greater flexibility for manufacturer's seasonal needs. New Item improvements were measured by ACV against non-covered stores.Categories: HBC, Suncare, Footcare, Over The Counter Drugs (PL)
(39)*
$3.2
million Sale of Specialized Merchandising Services to Assist New Chain Owner in: Retailer: Large Drug Store ChainProblem: The Drug Store Chain had acquired a number of other Chain Stores. The new owners did not know inventories, fixtures, square footage, layouts, aisle widths, etc.Sales Cycle Notes: Associate was introduced to prospect by his service company, led the proposal and presentation efforts, multiple meetings, instrumental in closing the sale due to his experience and specialty skillsSolutions Notes: Solution was a systematic store by store program to survey all stores and collect and organize the needed information. The solution included training and a software system. Project was approved and started in August 2007.Category: Drug (PG)
(48)* $1 Million+ Services Sold, Results: Big Results On Small Budget. $800,000 in sales gained in 17 weeks on First to Market Launch of Fat Free Pringles. Gained a 32% market share with a company that typically earned 9%. Retailer: National Drug CompanyProblem: Proctor and Gamble was launching a new Elestra product with Pringles and needed retail merchandising.Solution Notes: Provided a complete new launch program for logistics, marketing, in-store programs, advertising and merchandising with a limited budget, Worked with all aspects of the company to ensure product was in-stock and displayed for success. Developed a competitive program in-store, at distribution center and by operations to incent for high sales and margins.Category: Drug (PG) |
=================Walmart Successes (often cannot disclose full names and details)================
(59)*
$100 Million+ Sales Gain, $1.7 Million Cost Savings over
10 Years
Category: HBC, Near-HBC Details: http://tomingraminc.sharepointsite.net/PublicWebSite/Shared%20Documents/NoOneSelleratWalMartv3.pdf (22)* 20% Improvement in New Item Speed to Shelf. Shared Merchandising Teams (Broker Coverage) Not Getting Job Done. Established Dedicated Team Program for Fortune 500 Health and Beauty Manufacturer in Mass Merchandising (Wal*Mart) and Drug Channels*. Syndicated model being used was falling short in out of stocks, void fills and display compliance. Also provided greater flexibility for manufacturer's seasonal needs. New Item improvements were measured by ACV against non-covered stores.Categories: HBC, Suncare, Footcare, Over The Counter Drugs (PL) (26)* Promotion Compliance: Developed Program at Wal*Mart for Auditing Stores for Compliance with Promotions*. Marketing department had no history or baseline to judge promotions from. Current effort is to establish the baseline.Category: Wal*Mart (PL) (33)* $1.7 Million+ Savings On Merchandising Work. 425,000 Hours of Merchandising Services Provided at 20%+ Cost Savings Through Data-Driven Merchandising. Demonstrated that targeted project work produced a better ROI for manufacturers and retailers than generic continuity work. Had to become good at dealing with a fluctuating work load, using part time work force.* Grew base of business from 72,340 hours per year to 425,531 hours per year over five years. Growth came by transitioning from continuity work to project work. Included Hair Care Resets for 6 years running, cosmetics resets at one mass merchandiser and becoming the preferred provider at another mass merchandiser. Discovered that Project work was often 20% to 25% more cost-efficient than continuity work because of significantly less drive time. Had to become good at dealing with a fluctuating work load. Transitioned to part time work force.Categories: HBC, Cosmetics (JV) (60)* Outsourcing In-house Merchandising Team
Details http://tomingraminc.sharepointsite.net/PublicWebSite/Shared%20Documents/OutsourcingInHouseMerchTeam2.pdf
(84)*
17% increase in sales over the past 4 weeks in WalMart [4th Qtr]
Mature Product Increases from 40% Share to 57% Share in 4 Weeks
No doubt
this compliance is responsible for the 17% increase in sales over the
past 4 weeks.
We really
appreciate your support and partnership!”
… thanks to
your team ... for another stellar year!”
…as I told
you before, ... results in WM is best in class!”
Category: Near-HBC, (DY) |
=================Target Successes (often cannot disclose full names and details)================
(60.5) (Primarily at Target) Grew Merchandising
Company Services Sales from $3 million to $15 million in 3 Years as VP of Sales.
Key Category Wins were Jewelry and
Sunglasses.
$3 million to $7.2 million in
year one, $7.2 million to $12.5 million in year two, $12.5 million to about $15
million in year three (partial year).
(62)
Results: Increased product on shelf
from 50% of stores to 100% of stores Problem: New product cut in to 1250 stores, big coop dollars, on 50% stores on shelf after 30 days. Category: Snack
(63)
Results: 26% Increase in Sales on
Accessory Category Problem: Wanted Merchandising Program as effective as Target’s. Sales Cycle Notes: Required to do test head-to-head with competitor. Test including set, training, merchandising. Studied buyer’s data and surveys, reported on success. Solutions Notes: Designed schematic flow, merchandising program solution. Category: Jewelry |
=================National Grocery Retailer Successes (often
cannot disclose full names and details)================
(13)*
22% Annual
Increase In Diaper Sales For 56 Store Chain,
Completely Displaced a
Competitor in 3 Weeks!*
Associate’s team discovered extreme dissatisfaction with a diaper manufacturer.
Associate went to a competitive diaper manufacturer, jointly developed a new
planogram, closed retailer and completed resets in three weeks, completely
displacing the original diaper manufacturer.
(15)*
Gained
Approximately $11.1 Million in Incremental Cosmetics Sales for Manufacturers in
One Year,
Took 30% of Shelf Space Away From “No-Show”
Competitors.
Bundling Multiple Store Calls*.
Associate
discovered that a competitor’s merchandising team did not show up for a 210
store cosmetics reset. Associate’s team was able to convert 30% of
competitor’s shelf space to their manufacturer. See discussion of
clustering in health and beauty success story.
(21)*
$125 Million in Additional Sales for Manufacturer by Reducing
Out Of Stocks by 5% (estimated),
$1 Million Cost Savings
through
Outsourcing of
In-House Merchandising Team.*
Associate managed the team and its P&L. Achieved
approximately 5% reduction in Out of Stocks (key goal of the effort) and saved
manufacturer $1 million per year in merchandising costs at the same time.
(Manufacturer’s sales are about $4.5 Billion. We are assuming that a 5%
reduction in out of stocks will result in additional sales of approximately $125
million.)
(23)*
$4,307,000 Sales Increase Through Out of Stock
Reductions.
Established Dedicated Team Program for Fortune 500 Paper Goods Manufacturer.*
Specific Goal Was
Out of Stock Reductions. In-stock percentages grew from 99.23% to 99.67%.
Ultimately added promotion compliance and store level selling to the program.
(28)* Manufacturer Saves $2.5 Million over 5 Years, Improves Distribution 4%, Reduces New Item Speed to Shelf by 30 Days, Increases Displays Sold by 17%, through Outsourcing of In-House Merchandising Team (estimated).* Associate led effort that outsourced the work of 250 full-time people to a 3rd party. 65% of the manufacturer’s employees accepted positions at the 3rd party at a reduced salary. Reporting capabilities for account management team also were improved.Category: Cosmetics (PL) (31)* $59 Million Incremental Sales for European Grocery Wholesaler In One Year by Reducing Out Of Stocks and Voids through Data-Driven Merchandising. Should Increase for Next Several Years*. Distributor had been using data to identify problems in retail stores for years (voids, out of stocks, new items, promotion compliance.) Problem was that the distributor’s manufacturers, retailers, brokers and merchandising companies “owned” responsibility for resolving the problems (and the job was not getting done.) Goal for first year of program was a 2% improvement ($80 million.) Achieved $59 million improvement due to the data-driven merchandising solution (quote from distributor.) Note that these are hard dollars of increased sales from products that are authorized to be on shelves, but are not there. Associate sold project and designed approach that produced results.Category: Wholesaler Sales Increase, International (DK)
(68)*
On Shelf
Availability improvement from 84% to 95%, Results in Sales Gain of $297 Million Manufacturer: Fortune 25 HBC/Food Manufacturer Problem: Manufacturer was using syndicated merchandising services provided by a third party, who could not focus on specific opportunities provide adequate time in-store. Dedicated merchandising team provided the ability to train, motivate, focus, provide adequate in-store time. Solutions Notes: Action based In-Store procedures supported by technology ensured consistency in execution, and the basis for sustainable results over time Category: Grocery Products – Dry and Perishable (WV)
(70)*
New Product
Speed to Shelf Results in $12 Million Sales Gain Manufacturer: Fortune 25 Foods Company Problem: New Product introduction processes in place focused primarily on headquarter selling. Communication problems between Account Teams, Customer Service and Merchandising resulted in multiple execution failures. Symptoms included items being stuck in Distribution Centers, not getting to the shelf quickly (in some instances until 8 weeks+ later.) Solutions Notes: Achieved through a “Situation Room” approach to New Item Intro process plus better communication between account team / customer service / merchandising team through handhelds and systems. Resulted in faster order placement / confirmation, item code validation and ordering by the merchandising team. Sales gain calculated by reducing speed to shelf time from 12 weeks to 4 weeks (approx.) This added another full month of sales to the Year 1 Sales Volume ($12 Million). Category: Near-HBC, Grocery (WV)
(71)*
On Shelf
Availability and Field Merchandising Disciplines Yield Sales Gain of $400
Million+ Manufacturer: US Division of International Pharmaceutical Company Problem: Store execution was not achieving targets, On Shelf Availability levels were not improving. Third Party merchandising was not generating the ROI necessary to justify the cost. Solutions Notes: A Dedicated Team model was developed and implemented, requiring a completely new merchandising team. Risk concerns were quickly put to rest in-store execution was improved and documented during the first 14 weeks. In-store execution increased every month. After 24 months, the equivalent sales growth driven by the new team approached 6% of annual sales. Category: HBC Categories (WV)
(104)* 90 Day Sales Gain of
$36 Million, Out of Stocks Cut by 50%, Voids Eliminated in Test of 1100 Stores.
Sales gain verified by POS data from test stores, exceeding same store sales
from two control groups.
Problem: Retail merchandising "conditions in-store" reports were over-stating actual in-store conditions. Shelf sections were poor, out of stocks significant. Broker reports were always positive, and POS based reports were supporting what appeared to be a 98% "on-shelf" level. (This was actually an inferred observation based on 98% of items selling and scanning, but it significantly understated the opportunity to improve sales.) Solutions Notes: Used existing retail merchandising force and created an entirely new ‘Retail Call Procedure” for a set of test stores. Trained – implemented – monitored, in ruthless detail on results and progress. Measured sales performance in stores on coverage by existing Retail Force and also stores with no merchandising coverage at all. For this test, there was little done to “match test stores with comparable sister stores of same attributes”. Test Stores: Every SKU was “touched” and documentation was made of: SKU’s on shelf and tagged, SKU’s that had tags up but were out of stock, SKU’s that were authorized for the store/POG but were not tagged and on shelf. All results documented and the data used as the Baseline for the Test Stores Performance. Upon completion of the Distribution documentation, remedial action was taken to correct: SKU’s out of stock – look for back room inventory, inventory in other locations, check order status and book inventory status, inform manager and validate that the item is on order, and if not get it ordered and fix inventory figure if necessary. SKU’s authorized but non tagged on shelf – contact manager, and validate ‘authorized status and place on POG’ and order product , get tag made, put tag on shelf and return when appropriate to ensure that the item is cut in on shelf. Did this for 13 weeks. Control Stores and Non Covered Stores: Simply tracked by POS reports. In the Control Stores where the Field Force was covering and working the stores, they continued "business as usual". In the non-covered stores there was no activity at all. Monitoring: POS for all stores were monitored, POS for each store group (test, control, non-covered) were monitored. Category: HBC Categories, Grocery (WV)
(105)* Unilever, 90 Day Sales
Gain of $132 Million, New Item Speed to Shelf went from 85 % ACV in 12 weeks to
85% ACV in 8 weeks. Sales of "Display Shippers"
and Distribution Improved Significantly.
Great Example of “Take Back the Shelf” Program. Extremely large
scale effort involving all retail stores for a Fortune 25 manufacturer.
Demonstrated a large HBC manufacturer can significantly improve its performance
Without Capital Expenditure. Note on the Value of the "Gray Haired Types": This result was achieved even though many technically capable analysts and younger managers did not see the need or opportunity. Associate and other "gray haired types" got this result accomplished anyway. Associates report that younger managers, especially those that have not spent significant personal time "in-store, resolving problems" often overlook these needs and opportunities. Category: HBC Categories, Grocery (WV) |
General Electric, the second best performance we know of: GE has grown to $181 Billion in Sales from 2000 to 2008 (5.00% Growth) while averaging 11.68% Net After Tax Profits and 396% Return on Shareholder Investment. GE as a company has made the transition to 26%+ of its revenues coming from Services.
Mark Olsen - IBM Executive, Summary Background
(708)
High Margin
Win, SAP Application
Services Unit:
Improved Gross Profit from 31% in Commodity IT Outsourcing to 40.5%*,
Grew SAP Unit from $0 to $100 Million.
Built important relationships with SAP senior
executives. Acquired small
software company and brought in talent to achieve. (MO)
(709)
High Margin Win:
Improved Margins from Breakeven to 45% Gross Profit*.
Grew IT Hardware, Software and Services Unit from $400
Million to $550 Million in Three Years.
Stopped mindless responses to RFPs, requiring
win-win conditions before responding.
Simultaneously reduced headcount
from 379 to 65. Created new incentive system which significantly
contributed to improvements. General Motors Account. (MO)
(710)
High Margin
Win:
Improved Gross
Profit from 35% to 43%*.
Grew IT Hardware, Software and Services
Unit from $390 Million to $650 Million in Two Years.
Program aided by partnering with application software providers.
Started program with Merrill Lynch and expanded to Goldman Sachs,
Lehman Brothers, NYSE, NASDAC, AIG, NY Life, Metropolitan Life, Bank of NY.
Program was P&L based blended pricing system including
hardware teams, software teams and services teams. (MO)
(711)
High Margin
Win: Maintained $800 Million
profit contribution while company lost 15%+ market share per year Global Finance
Unit*. Turned sales force from
"order takers" to new business "hunters". Accomplished by
developing program to finance competitor's equipment as well as in-house
equipment (despite internal opposition.) (MO) |
Carl Larsen
- IBM Executive, Summary Background (742)
IBM Global Services, Southwest US: $0 to
$100 Million in Two Years, Profitable Despite Extreme Growth.*
Closed Four Major Sales in First Year.
As one of the founders of what became
IBM Global Services, Associate led the region covering the Southwest US.
Unit was created to respond to IBM's rapidly declining margins during the 1990s.
(CL) (743)
Los Angeles Unified School District: Sold $6.5
Million in outsourced services during first year of IBM Global Services
startup*. Sold
to both the office of the Assistant Superintendent and IT Department.
Partners made a significant contribution.
(CL) (744)
Los Angeles Department of Water and Power: Sold
$4.5 Million in outsourced services during first year of IBM Global Services
startup*.
Sold to Agency Head, not IT Department.
(CL) (745)
AARP: Sold $5 Million+ in outsourced services
during first year of IBM Global Services startup*.
Sold to Deputy
Director of Membership, and the IT Department.
(CL) (746)
Major Los Angeles Newspaper: Led Team that
Ultimately Sold $4 Million in outsourced services
during first year of IBM Global Services startup*.
Sold to Assistant Senior Editor, not IT
Department. Work included
applications for advertising in the greater Los Angeles area. (CL) (747) State Government: Led teams selling and/or delivering $120+ Million in outsourced services*. (CL) Major Sales Included:
(749)
Major Consumer Telecom Equipment Provider: Led Team that
Ultimately Sold $2 Million+ in Outsourced Services to Support New Product (Cell
Phone / Two-Way Radio)*.
Work included vehicle registration
system. Sold to Head of Channel
Marketing, not IT Department. Work
included off shore call center and technical support. (CL) (748)
Texas Instruments:
Sales support for $1 Million+ sale of hardware,
software and services*. Work
included accounts payable processing and IT facility management, (CL) (749)
Intel:
Sales support technical manager for $1 Million+ sale of
hardware, software and services*.
Work included system to support general ledger, accounts payable, account
receivable, payroll, sales order processing, purchasing and inventory
applications. (CL) (750)
AMD:
Sales support technical manager for $1 Million+ sale of
hardware, software and services*.
Work included system to support general ledger, accounts payable, account
receivable, payroll, sales order processing, purchasing and inventory
applications. (CL) (751)
Atari:
Sales support technical manager for $1 Million+ sale of
hardware, software and services*.
Work included system to support general ledger, accounts payable, account
receivable, payroll, sales order processing, purchasing and inventory
applications. (CL) (752)
Mervyns:
Led technical sales support for
$1 Million+ sale of hardware, software and services to
this major retailer.*
(CL) (753)
GAP:
Led technical sales support for
$2.5 Million sale of hardware, software and services to
this major retailer.*
Work included business analysis and support for new merchandising application
development. (CL) (754)
Macy's:
Sold $1 Million+ Application Development System*.
Work included application development for merchandising and advertising systems.
(CL) (755)
Fireman's Fund:
Led Team that Sold $2 Million in Outsourced
Services*. Work included offshore
help desk and call center support. (CL) |
(600) Fenwick (Manufactures
forklifts) 50% of Fenwick’s
£500 million in revenues come from services developed over the past 15 years.
Services
include Maintenance, Repair, Spare Parts, Insurance, Training, Fleet
Management, Short Term and Long Term Rentals, Financing, Sales of Used
Equipment (Consignment?).**
(601) General Electric, Financial Performance Summary: GE has grown to $181 Billion in Sales from 2000 to 2008 (5.00% Growth) while averaging 11.68% Net After Tax Profits and 396% Return on Shareholder Investment. GE as a company has made the transition to 26%+ of its revenues coming from Services. This success is second only to IBM’s average of 10% Net After Tax Profits, 641% Return on Shareholder Investment, 3% revenue growth to $99.8 Billion and 57% of revenues coming from services (for roughly the same period.)Example of the benefits that accrue: Most of GE's competitors in turbines struggle to charge more than $90-$110 per hour for technical support. GE Energy charges $500-$600 per hour for the same technician due to its efficient network of remote servicing. (HBR article)** (601.01)
GE Energy, Doug Terrell,
Retired Head of GE's 43,000 Person Sales Organization. (601.02) GE Energy, Doug’s Success Lessons: How to Sell to Senior Executive Decision Makers and Avoid the Commodity Trap of Lower Level Buyers* (DT) (601.03)
Part 1:
Focus on the Revenue Side - Make Money for Them*
(DT) (601.04)
Part 2:
Faster, Bigger Paybacks than Your Competitors*
(DT) (601.05)
Part 3:
Becoming Part of Customer's Planning Cycle*
(DT) (601.06)
Part 4:
How Being Better on the Revenue Side Helps You be
Better on the Cost Side*
(DT) (601.07)
35% Contribution Margin on $47 Billion in Services Revenue:
How GE Avoids the Trap of Underrating Services*
(DT) (601.08)
Incentive
Systems Work: How We Increased Sales from $640 Million to $1.1 Billion
in One Year,
to $1.4 Billion the Next* (DT)
(601.1)
GE Energy, Aero Derivative Turbines (jet engines in unconventional uses e.g.
power generation, gas pipeline compression, ship
propulsion).
Grew
Services Sales from $250 Million to $540 Million and Operating Profit from
$18 Million to $95 Million in Two Years.
Growth was 50% acquisition, 50% organic.*
(DW)
(610) Mark Grant, former General Manager, GE Service Shops, GE Power Systems Marketing, GE Power Systems Engineering Services, GE Power Systems Six Sigma, Former President Cooper Rolls Royce, Former CEO Stewart and Stevenson. Former CEO Halcore Group. (610.1) Value Pricing Win: Grant was responsible for 25 value-priced sales of steam turbine services in one year. These sales averaged $4 million revenue and 50%+ margin. The best example was Brunswick Paper, where the GE team identified $7 million per year in annual savings and was able to charge the customer $6 million while earning $5 million in margin*. (MG)* (610.2) Stewart and Stevenson, oil, gas, power industry services provider and manufacturer of vehicles for U.S. government: Grant led growth from $6 per share to $35 per share at sell-out over four years.* (MG)* (610.3) Halcore, manufacturer of ambulances: Grant led stock price improvement from $4 per share to $27 per share and sell-out over six years.* (MG)* (611) Jane Mills, a Mechanical Engineer with Proctor& Gamble out of college, spent her first 15 years learning to optimize manufacturing environments for General Electric Industrial Control Systems, Emerson Electric and Fisher Controls. Rose to running a $140 million P&L with five divisions, 1,000 sales and operating staff and 18 sales rep offices. (611.1) Saftey-Kleen Success: As Senior VP, built Western Division and Canada to $200 million (25% of company total). While company was exiting bankruptcy, brought her division from a loss to #1 revenue and EBITDA (>10%) among the divisions for five out of six years. Mills attributes much of her success to applying the disciplines of lean manufacturing to services and sales.
(602)
Heidelberg (Heidelberger Druckmaschinen Ag, printing press manufacturer,
$3.1 billion sales in 2010) Summary:
44% of
Revenues From Services.
Products consistently sell for a 20%+ premium over
most competitors.
Corrected profit leakage in service agreements. Invested in remote
monitoring, other technology, resulting in better profits and extensive
additional services sold to customers.
Heidelberg added a “consumables” business that added 12.5%+ to U.S. Sales.
(Public financial statements,
HBR article, BB)* (602.2) Major U.S. Commercial Printer Success Story: Closed initial order for $14.5 Million, charging approx. 20% more than next lowest price competitor. Customer ultimately purchased $40 million+ in product and $10 million+ in services (approx.). Key technical / solution edge that won the business and kept it for 20+ years: Heidelberg designed custom printing systems / solutions that produced high-precision color output needed by the customer. Additional services that mattered: (Not all services applied in this case. Listed below to assist in understanding Heidelberg's strengths.) (BB)*
1.
Pre-sales design / engineering of printing solutions (sometimes
extensive, usually done at no charge.)
2. Process / Application Improvement Consulting
(Evaluate what customer trying to accomplish and recommend best approach.
Might include services, products, process / productivity improvements, plant
workflow / layout, etc.. Sometimes performed for fee, sometimes free
as part of sales process.)
11.
Refurbishment of existing mechanically sound equipment
with new electronics, et. al. (while competitors try to sell new equipment
only).**
(602.3)
Associate’s Best Sales Tools & Techniques:
(603) Air Liquide, (provides
industrial gasses).
A Leader in Building Services Business
for Process Manufacturers. (Ulaga, Reinartz, Journal
of Marketing, "Hybrid Offerings...", advance copy,
2011. Company name not
disclosed, but probably is Air Liquide**)
Some examples of services wins and services businesses built include:
1. Performance-Based Contracts for Total Gas and Supply Management for a Semiconductor Plant 2. Welding Audits at auto plant 3. Consumption usage analysis resulted in significant cost reduction for oxygen cylinders 4. "Free-to-Fee" (Now able to charge for previously free services.) E.g. Cylinder connection to customer systems, Cylinder on-site inventory 5. Differentiated Themselves from Commodity Gas Suppliers: E.g. Expert at food preservation in a meat processing plant (instead of just supplying a commodity gas.)
(604) Schneider Electric,
(French
electrical equipment manufacturer). U.S. Division
Grew Services from $24 million to $400 million/year
at 32% Contribution Margin from 1994 to 2009.
(From 1% to 10% of sales.)
Total sales grew from $2.4 billion to $4 billion,
demonstrating product sales gains that accompany effective services sales.
Parent Company changed workforce from
7.7% Services and Projects in 2008 to 12.9% in 2010. Produced 15%
EBITA in 2009. Named an executive vp and board member
to the job of discovering additional services revenue opportunities****.
Switched from cost plus pricing to value based
pricing.*
(604.1) Schneider Electric, U.S. Division. Grew Services from $1.5 million to $9.75 million in 4 years at 32% Contribution Margin in 3 State Midwestern Region. Accomplished with ZERO INCREMENTAL PEOPLE. Total sales grew from $78 million to $120 million, demonstrating product sales gains that accompany effective services sales. (SL)* (604.2) Schneider Electric, U.S. Division. $1 Million+ Services Success Story, Beating Competitor's Product Sales With a Service: Customer Problem: When a 30 year old electric substation need replacement (e.g. 4,000 volt system for a refinery), competitors want to sell all new equipment, which creates three weeks+ of disruption and outages. Schneider pioneered "in-place-refurbishment" for both its equipment and competitor's equipment, which resulted in near zero down time. Ultimately was able to earn more profit than selling new equipment to customer because of extreme value customer placed on no outages. (SL)* (604.3) Schneider Electric, U.S. Division. "How to Get Product Sales Guys to Sell Services": See results achieved by (SC). Key techniques: (a) "How to be two out of three bids." Customers would always need three bids. Make sure your bids included a competitive bid for new equipment and a bid for refurbishment services as a second, competitive bid. This would leave one open bid slot for a competitor. Regularly having two of three bid slots wins a lot of business. (b) "Do you want fries with that?" It sounds trite, but rigor, training and demands on the sales force to sell services are, in part, this simple. (c) We must get beyond the "services is just the warranty group - a necessary evil" mentality". (d) We must make selling services formally evaluated as part of performance management and compensation. (e) We added a small dedicated technical services sales force to assist the product sales force in proposing and closing business. (SL)* (604.4) Schneider Electric, U.S. Division. $1 Million+ Services Success Story, Beating Competitor's Product Sales With a Service: Capitalized on Competitor's Tendency to Always Propose New Equipment. Able to place a service engineer on-site with a major cigarette manufacturer for two years doing nothing but refurbishing the electrical portions of older, mechanically sound cigarette producing machines. (SL)*
(605) SKF,
($9.7 Billion Bearing
manufacturer) SKF Has Done a Magnificent Job of
Rapidly Growing a Business that Consistently Charges 10%+ More than Its
Competitors (In what could easily be a commodity product)
and its 2010 Profit before Tax Was 12.3%.
However, SKF does not report services separately.
Our best information is that
SKF is working toward the goal of reporting
a significant percent of revenues from services.
SKF has developed services around
the core bearing product and over 10 years acquired the know-how to
become a world leader in condition
monitoring, industrial sealing, lubrication system, vibration analysis,
bearings technical support, maintenance services, training.
Tools and techniques that help sell services
and avoid commodity price competition:**
(a) A Business Case Simulator and Benefits Tracking System: The "Documented Solution Program" Has Documented $2.3 Million in Savings Where Customers Used SKF Instead of Competitive Solutions. Includes full cost of products (e.g. bearings, seals) consumables (lubrication) systems (condition monitoring, lubrication) labor (installation, maintenance, replacement) downtime / outages, electricity, etc. Demonstrates that SKF products, which consistently produce a 30%+ longer life for just a 10% cost premium, coupled with the value added services, produce significant savings over 1 year, 3 year, 5 year, 10 years or longer. (b) Key Services that SKF Adds to bearing and seal products: 1. Up Front Engineering / Design (usually free with pre-sales or declined because customers think they can do it themselves). 2. Predictive and Preventive Maintenance Programs 3. Field Problem Resolution when problems occur, including engineers available for phone and on-site consultation and a Test / Simulation lab which can duplicate nearly any condition (this may be the best facility in the world and the strongest differentiator SKF has). 4. Note that a critical mass of locally available service technicians appears as a key competitive differentiator in multiple excellent services companies. 5. Condition Monitoring, which allows SKF to remotely monitor vibrations from bearing and predict failures in time to prevent outages. A recent development includes hardware and software to make condition monitoring systems portable. 6. Lubrication Systems to keep everything working. 7. Periodic Maintenance to prevent failures. 8. Spare Parts, Warranty Replacement. 9. Bundled Services Offerings of all the above, including Performance Based Contracts (Uptime / Time Between Failure) to offer a total program and total savings. 10. Reconditioning / Refurbishment centers in key places around the world have reduced motor repair cycle time by 50% in some cases. 11. Training / Education for Customers (where knowledge transfer is desired and makes sense.) 12. Numerous programs help make distributors and resellers effective at maintaining SKF's high standards of quality: Certified Maintenance Partner program, Certified Rebuilder Program for Electric Motors (56 repair shops) whicha are audited and recertified regularly SKF Distributor College offers 34 courses and is approaching 100,000 issued certificates.**
(606) ABB,
(Process control
equipment manufacturer). 2007 through 2009
averaged 15.5%+ of revenues from services.
2010 net after tax of 8.1%
(recession year) on $31.5 bb in revenue. Will selectively
support a competitor's equipment in order to penetrate a new account.**
(607) Hilti, (Power
Hand Tools for Construction Industry)
Moved to a “Pay by the Hole” Pricing Model to
Move Customers from Commodity Cost Focus to Total Cost /
Best Value Focus. The method
taught to the direct sales force is to provide analysis
including the primary product (e.g. a drill) consumables (e.g. bits, anchors,
fillers, foam) measuring device, safety equipment, material waste, labor
(including cost of fatigue and rework) to calculate the total costs of producing
finished holes for a construction crew per year. The offering
includes a leasing service which replaces the tool to
always provide best performance and reduces invested capital.
The overall result was as
savings of $15,000+ per year for an average commercial construction company,
plus the intangible benefit of providing the construction
crew with the best available tools.
(JB)*(607.1) Hilti, "Fleet Management" Concept Moves Customers from Commodity Cost Focus to Total Cost / Best Value Focus: Uses the analogy of a managing a fleet of trucks to help customers understand the factors described in item (607). Helps customers understand that the lowest cost truck (or drill) does not usually produce the lowest "cost per mile" (or cost per hole), because the lowest cost per mile has to consider maintenance cost, fuel mileage, tires, replacement, etc. (JB)* (607.2) Hilti, Special Circumstances and Geographic Opportunity. Leasing Services Offering Captures 50% of Market for Commercial Power Hand Tools in Switzerland, vs. 15% (approx.) in USA. Unique Circumstances Allows Special Dominance of a Market, Creates High Barriers to Switching for Customers. Possible Due to Hilti Being Privately Held and (Arguably) the Regulatory / Economic Climate of a European Country. (JB)* (607.3) Hilti, Additional Techniques for Resisting Commodity Price Pressure. Believes a Direct Sales Force is Required to Sustain Margins for Premium Product. Shifted to "Customer Results / Solution / Outcome" Focus (Instead of "What We Do" Focus). Taught Entire Culture - "What the Customer Is Really Buying is a Finished, Completed HOLE - Done Right, the First Time." Hilti uses terms like "Focus on the Application" and questions like "How can I make you faster?". (JB)*
(608) Rick Wallace,
Specialist in Growing Manufacturing-Related, High Margin Services Businesses.
Over his 30+ year career,
Associate produced the following results, generally following the same key steps
illustrated in (608.1.a)*
(608.1) Rockwell Automation
(Global Manufacturing Solutions Business):
As Senior Vice President / Group General Manager,
Associate built a group of businesses with the following results over 30 months,
which encompassed the 2001 recession (RW)* (a) Process
Automation Business:
Grew from $50 million to $150 million at 25%+ margins* 1. How found
Core Technology / Process / Quality Competitive Advantage:
Started with a premise / goal:
e.g.
How expand into batch manufacturing market? (known to be a $15 billion
industry). Studied internal
capabilities and customers. e.g.
Discovered small customer successes in batch
manufacturing. Associate PERSONALLY
interviewed existing customers and prospects in target niches.
“What are your needs?” (NOT
focused on “Here’s what we sell”).
e.g. Discovered pharmaceutical manufacturers did not
care about manufacturing!
(Perceived
it as just cost center.)
Core
concern was getting drugs through FDA approval.
Focused efforts on super-high paybacks for
prospects in niches 2. Niches
Focused on and Results:
Pharmaceuticals:
Key Result Needed by Client:
Shorten new drug development time (Big
Win). Marine:
Key Result Needed by Client:
Aircraft Carrier Automation Control Systems
(Big Win) [Hired retired Admiral, did joint
venture with Sperry Rand, able to displace Siemens].
Food and Beverage:
Key Result Needed by Client:
Improve food processing manufacturing.
Automotive: [This was
core business when Associate joined Rockwell] (b) Integration of
Factory Automation with ERP Systems Business:
Grew to $100 Million at 40%+ margins.
Premise / goal:
How expand up from plant automation into Information Management systems?
Involved numerous systems, including scheduling, ERP, automation, etc.* (c) Asset
Management Business.
Grew from $170 million to $270 million at 35%+ margins.
Consolidated a group
of unprofitable business units into a focused whole with the following
elements:* 1. Predictive
Maintenance: Found that 40% average
plant’s costs on maintenance (Big Win.) 2. Multi-vendor
spare parts: An outsourced service.
Took on responsibility for spare parts inventory.
(Not a big win, but most helpful in marketing) 3. Customer
Support Business (Grew from $100 million to $150 million) 4. Moved from
T&M work to contracts, built a contracts backlog and long term customer
commitments instead of “immediate cancellation” terms. 5. Significant
profit improvement due to contracts, tiers of service 6. 24 X 7 Call
center – phone and remote support 7. 24 X 7 On
site support 8. Multi-Vendor
support 9. Training (608.2) Contract Manufacturing for Electronics,
Telecom, Industrial:
Built Four High Profit Service Businesses for $8.7
Billion Contract Manufacturer.
Consolidated
Services Group and Grew from $800 million and losing
money to $1 billion in One Year demonstrated Net Profit run rate of 10.5%
(3.5 times company’s average profit.
This resulted in board
approval to grow
to $3.5 billion in 5 years, but plan was not executed.
Some explanation required.)
Some details on how accomplished: (RW)* (a)
Capitalized
on Strengths: Supply Chain and fulfillment capability
(c)
Services Businesses Developed:
1. Offered
fulfillment services with contract manufacturing to provide higher value: 2.
New Product Design and Launch
(When Customer Could Not Do Themselves): (Grew to
$25M)
Created by providing new products where customer's internal engineering lacked
capacity 3.
Product repair and customer
support business. (Grew to $300M):
Integrated product repair, reverse logistics and customer support
business Provided product and engineering
feedback to customer engineering
(608.3) Equipment Conditioning Monitoring for HVAC
and Engine Parts for Cruise Ships:
Changed business from selling software to selling
service. Shortened
sales cycle by changing target buyer from capital acquisition by purchasing
person to expense item for maintenance person.
This startup business became
viable and was sold. (RW)* (608.4) Factory Automation Control Services and
Software Business (DEC) Grew
business from $250 million to $500 million in three years.
Some details on how
accomplished: (RW)* (a) DEC’s
Problem: DEC had very strong
technology but no reputation in the target niche (b) Approached
the problem by vertical industries / niches:
Discreet manufacturing, Semiconductor, Batch, Automotive (c)
Client’s High Payback Need / Problem:
Getting information from factory floor equipment to other major systems
and equipment that run on different standards (d) Solution for
DEC and Client: 1.
Teamed up with factory floor automation providers 2.
Developed software “middleware” to reduce interfaces required
between dissimilar equipment. e.g.
reduced from 40 interfaces to 8 at one plant 3. Became part of industry standards 5. Built integrated global network of expertise centers for each industry for solution design and customer demonstrations (609) John Deere (Tractors, Farm Implements) Services increased from 17% of Revenues to 36% while Company value increased by 76% from 1995 to 2005 (measured by Tobin's Q, Journal of Marketing, Sept 2008, Fang, et.a.l) (611) Otis Elevator Success: Increased Profits from 8.4% to 17.4% (not clear if EBITDA /before / after tax) from 2001 to 2003 through services strategy. Key issue was extremely slow to no growth for new elevators / escalators - able to grow through services. (SR) (Baveja, Gilbert, HBR, 2004, both from Bain, referencing internal Bain study) (612) Applied Materials Success: Useful precedent for chip manufacturers. Concentrated on parts management, maintenance cost reduction, uptime and chip output. Tested services (and needed capabilities) with major customers, found what worked, rolled out to other customers. (Baveja, Gilbert, HBR, 2004, both from Bain, referencing internal Bain study) |
(613) Carpenter, Jack,
Specialist in Direct, Major Account, High Value
Industrial Sales. Highlights from Carpenter's 30+ years of
experience:
(613.1) The Norton Company (ultimately Saint-Gobain). Abrasives, Diamond Cutting Tools and Grinding Wheels for highly engineered, specialty applications. Customers: Automotive, Military, Aerospace, General Industrial, Oil & Gas. Participated / helped lead transition from 100% of sales through distribution to 60% through distribution, 40% direct to major accounts. Direct account sales grew$400 million during Carpenter’s tenure (approximate, see Harvard Business School case). Some highlights: (JC)*
(a) Increased direct major account sales from $0 to $400,000 in one year (approx.) Two state territory (Mississippi and Louisiana) with distributor sales of $350,000.
(b) Promoted to Chicago, took over largest and most mature of 50 Industrial Diamond territories in US, Grew direct account sales from $1.4 million to $2.0 million in three years (sales through distribution grew from $1 million to $1.1 million in same period.)
(c) Promoted to Application Engineering and other
roles, 90%+ in support of direct sales
(613.2)
FLEXcon Corporation,
Engineered Adhesive Coatings.
100% direct sales
(a) Grew direct sales territory from $3.5 million to $7 million in 3 years
(Texas, Oklahoma, Arkansas)
(b) Promoted to sales manager:
Re-staffed district, team of six sales people,
grew sales from $21 million to $30 million in four years
(613.3)
NOSCO
Printing Group,
Specially Engineered Labels and Packaging, VP Sales and Marketing
(a)
Refocused
business on selling directly to pharmaceutical companies
(b) Grew direct sales from $48 million to $52 million
over three years in difficult circumstances.
(50%
of sales were heavily price competitive and 50% were sold on value.)
(613.4)
Web
Industries (Conversion of bulk fabrics, films, adhesives and
printing into specialized applications and products)
(a)
Refocused company on medical industry with following direct, major account
wins:
1. Kimberly
Clark: $0 to $2 million
– made entry to child pull up pants market profitable for Kimberly
2. FCA:
$0 to $3 million
- made entry into adult incontinence products
3. Medical Mask Success: $0 to $4 million, outsourced customer’s in-house production, allowed them to enter new markets, highly engineered, high margin
6.0 First Command, Lamar Smith Success Story: Grew insurance broker's revenues from from $48 million to $210 million and grew profit from $6.1 million to $31 million over 22 years (14.7% Profit). Lamar attributes approximately $40 million (25%) of this sales growth to a long term sales process improvement project.* |
* Success stories, client quotes
and payback estimates are provided as general illustrations of past
performance and represent summaries of long term, complex efforts.
They are often used to teach concepts and lessons learned, and may have
been simplified considerably. Estimates of financial impact are
estimates only, and not intended to convey exact financial information.
Some have been altered to protect confidential information. We ask
that prospective clients contact our references and request specific
details of relevant success stories prior to any decision to use our
services.
TOM INGRAM AND ASSOCIATES, INC. 972-394-5736 tom@tomingraminc.com